This Not That: 12 Unexpected Valentine’s Day Gifts They’re Sure to Remember (2024)

All products featured on Vogue are independently selected by our editors. However, when you buy something through our retail links, we may earn an affiliate commission.

Love is in the air! Or is it? February 14—that heart-laden day with a fanciful origin tale—can magnify the full spectrum of emotions in any relationship. But whether or not Valentine’s Day envelops your own heart in a rose-colored veil, symbols of love are inescapable this time of year.

While there’s hardly a need to go all out on a gift, small tokens of affection are always appreciated—no matter how long your love has been blooming. For those with a strong feel for the holiday, our Valentine’s Day gift guide has small and grand gestures alike to pin down their love. For those looking for inspiration beyond the beribboned drugstore chocolates and hard-to-nab dinner reservations, our edit here is filled with ideas that are equal parts cheeky wink and wonderfully charming. Let’s jump right in.

Instead of an overpriced pre-fixe dinner…

Forgo the 7 PM Resy alerts! If the way to their heart is through their belly, chef up at home with a pasta kit from Roscioli—your tesoro will be most excited, almost more so than if you surprised them with a round-trip ticket to Rome. (Just kidding, that would indeed be better.) Embroidered placemats from Misette set the table, while anything—water included!—tastes better when sipped out of a Sophie Lou Jacobsen totem glass.

This Not That: 12 Unexpected Valentine’s Day Gifts They’re Sure to Remember (1)

Roscioli

signature pasta kit

This Not That: 12 Unexpected Valentine’s Day Gifts They’re Sure to Remember (2)

Misette

set-of-four linen placemats

This Not That: 12 Unexpected Valentine’s Day Gifts They’re Sure to Remember (3)

Sophie Lou Jacobsen

Totem glasses

Instead of grocery store flowers...

We’re not saying there’s anything wrong with raiding Trader Joe’s fresh flower stand, but if you want a true show-stopping arrangement that will blow up the group chat, a flower delivery is the way to go. Most of these can be shipped with or without vases, ahead of time, or a mere 24 hours before, and sometimes with chocolates for a little extra treat.

This Not That: 12 Unexpected Valentine’s Day Gifts They’re Sure to Remember (4)

Urbanstems

The Grower's choice

This Not That: 12 Unexpected Valentine’s Day Gifts They’re Sure to Remember (5)

BloomsyBox

pink peony tulips

This Not That: 12 Unexpected Valentine’s Day Gifts They’re Sure to Remember (6)

Flowerbx

roses and chocolate gift set

Instead of borrowing theirs…

Get yourself some sleepwear that’s chic and supremely comfy. Self-gifting is always in style.

Instead of another candle…

Scented matches!Incense sticks! Room spray! Your favorite plus-one might not live in a three-story townhouse on the Upper East Side, but that doesn’t mean their one-bedroom can’t smell like a home featured in an AD spread. These set a mood, and aren’t a fire hazard when you leave the kitchen unattended for… personal matters! A win.

This Not That: 12 Unexpected Valentine’s Day Gifts They’re Sure to Remember (9)

Buly1803

scented matches

This Not That: 12 Unexpected Valentine’s Day Gifts They’re Sure to Remember (10)

Ginori 1735

scented incense

This Not That: 12 Unexpected Valentine’s Day Gifts They’re Sure to Remember (11)

Loewe

Ivy room spray

Instead of second-guessing your relationship status…

No time like the present to lock it in.

This Not That: 12 Unexpected Valentine’s Day Gifts They’re Sure to Remember (12)

Chefanie

Relationship Status co*cktail napkins

This Not That: 12 Unexpected Valentine’s Day Gifts They’re Sure to Remember (13)

Georg Jensen

heart keyring

Instead of an awkward couple’s massage…

Explore a new kind of intimacy with a sensual body stone and oil that you can put to good use long after the clock strikes midnight.

This Not That: 12 Unexpected Valentine’s Day Gifts They’re Sure to Remember (14)

Kate McLeod

heart-shaped body stone

This Not That: 12 Unexpected Valentine’s Day Gifts They’re Sure to Remember (15)

Damask rose and bergamot body oil

This Not That: 12 Unexpected Valentine’s Day Gifts They’re Sure to Remember (17)

Frédéric Malle

Editions de Parfums Portrait of a Lady hair & body oil

Instead of a Birkin…

Who knows when their Baby Birkin will arrive? Until that fateful call comes, your sweetheart can gaze longingly at the bag’s muse, Jane Birkin, all while shuffling through the house in a pair of fuzzy Birkenstocks. It’s called manifesting!

This Not That: 12 Unexpected Valentine’s Day Gifts They’re Sure to Remember (18)

Sonic Editions

Birkin Paris​ 1970 print

This Not That: 12 Unexpected Valentine’s Day Gifts They’re Sure to Remember (19)

Birkenstock

Boston shearling clogs

Instead of a coffee date...

Perfect for the newly-coupled, skip the queue and brew cortados for two at home with fresh beans from Partners, then serve them in artful cups sure to spark a lively conversation.

This Not That: 12 Unexpected Valentine’s Day Gifts They’re Sure to Remember (20)

Anissa Kermiche

set of two coffee cups

This Not That: 12 Unexpected Valentine’s Day Gifts They’re Sure to Remember (21)

Partners Coffee

Elevate espresso

Instead of drugstore chocolates…

Spoil your sweet with treats almost as irresistible as they are, like cherries dipped in chocolate or matchsticks for your forever flame.

This Not That: 12 Unexpected Valentine’s Day Gifts They’re Sure to Remember (22)

Lavoratti 1938

Library box chocolates

This Not That: 12 Unexpected Valentine’s Day Gifts They’re Sure to Remember (23)

MarieBelle

chocolate-covered cherries box

This Not That: 12 Unexpected Valentine’s Day Gifts They’re Sure to Remember (24)

Choc on Choc

Perfect Match Belgian chocolate

Instead of a trail of red roses on the floor…

Romantic movie gestures aside, these won’t require any tidying up but get the sentiment across all the same.

This Not That: 12 Unexpected Valentine’s Day Gifts They’re Sure to Remember (25)

L'Objet

Rose Noire gift set

This Not That: 12 Unexpected Valentine’s Day Gifts They’re Sure to Remember (26)

Diptyque

roses scented candle

This Not That: 12 Unexpected Valentine’s Day Gifts They’re Sure to Remember (27)

Gucci

Rouge à Lèvres Voile

This Not That: 12 Unexpected Valentine’s Day Gifts They’re Sure to Remember (28)

Pat McGrath Labs

Skin Fetish Divine blush

Instead of playing games…

Challenge your knight in shining armor to a game of speed chess—the melty pawns are made of chocolate, after all—or a round of hearts if three’s a crowd.

This Not That: 12 Unexpected Valentine’s Day Gifts They’re Sure to Remember (29)

Compartes

Grandmaster chocolate chess set

This Not That: 12 Unexpected Valentine’s Day Gifts They’re Sure to Remember (30)

Bottega Veneta

playing cards

Instead of heart-shaped jewelry…

A set of heirloom-worthy earrings to remind them of your affection.

This Not That: 12 Unexpected Valentine’s Day Gifts They’re Sure to Remember (31)

Dorsey

Sabine lab-grown white sapphire drop earrings

This Not That: 12 Unexpected Valentine’s Day Gifts They’re Sure to Remember (32)

David Yurman

sculpted cable stud earrings

This Not That: 12 Unexpected Valentine’s Day Gifts They’re Sure to Remember (2024)
Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Reed Wilderman

Last Updated:

Views: 5940

Rating: 4.1 / 5 (52 voted)

Reviews: 91% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Reed Wilderman

Birthday: 1992-06-14

Address: 998 Estell Village, Lake Oscarberg, SD 48713-6877

Phone: +21813267449721

Job: Technology Engineer

Hobby: Swimming, Do it yourself, Beekeeping, Lapidary, Cosplaying, Hiking, Graffiti

Introduction: My name is Reed Wilderman, I am a faithful, bright, lucky, adventurous, lively, rich, vast person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.